I'd like to bounce a couple of story ideas off GAF. I need to narrow down what story Im doing for NaNo, so I can begin more intensive prepping/outlining. I always have a ton of ideas rattling around my head, and sometimes I get so excited about them I have a hard time realistically judging them, so maybe some outside opinions on which are good or bad, and most easily fleshed out could help narrow it down to something I can really make progress on this nano.
A lot of my ideas are my attempts at taking a fantasy trope and playing with it, to get a more unique idea, so fair warning.
1) A castlevania inspired adventure where the heroes have to travel across a blighted country to defeat a big bad. The idea here is twist on the idea of heroic bloodlines (i.e. like Aragorn or Belmonts, something your ancestor did puts a responsibility on all his descendants). In real life genealogy expands rapidly though, its not just one father one son, so here its been so long descendants are so common whole units of descendants are sent in until someone succeeds. The main hero finds out they're the product of an affair, and not of the bloodline at all, a fact which becomes important later. Setting would be more greco-roman than medieval fantasy.
2) A world of city states, where because of the presence of large alpha predators (dragons) human society developed differently. The biggest change is war is impossible since large groups of people attract dragon feeding frenzy's, ending badly for both sides. Dragons would be less ancient and wise magical creatures like most fantasy, but a bit more mundane, like flying sharks or T-Rexs. Society itself is more primitive since everyones more isolated. The story would be more exploration of this setting, as the main characters travel across it trying to discover their hidden heritage. A lot of potential places to explore new ideas but the main plot Ive come up with is fairly cliché by itself Im afraid. I might need to rethink it.
3) Real people in a fairy tale world. Kind of the inverse of a series like Fables or Once upon a time. A great cataclysm forces people from the real world to find refuge in a world of fairy tale characters, having to hide their origin. I got into Fables a lot after playing 'The wolf among us' Im afraid. This seems simplest, as it would take a lot of standard fairy tales tropes, but its my newest idea and one I haven't developed a lot, and while I think the ideas interesting, Im not sure Ill stay excited about it to finish it.
4) The only vampire. Yeah vampires are a bit passé now, but I think this is a somewhat original take. Whenever you deal with vampires public about their identity, it usually derails into stories about immortal cabals screwing around with humanity, because thats basically what would happen if people were immortal. But in this world, theres just one vampire/supernatural being, whos public about being a vampire. They were a major historical figure but disappeared long that most people just figured it was a fraud somehow. They suddenly reappear, and the story is about how the world deals with him/her, with a mystery of how it came to be they are the only vampire and why they disappeared in the first place.
Thoughts? Which ideas seem the most interesting? Which seem easiest to get 50k words from?