I don't get the love of Tracer's arse. It's barely there, flat as a board, a Hank Hill if he did squats level of a tiny, micro butt, any small and it would be nothing more than a crease denoting where her legs meet her back. It's just flat out (hah!), nothing to get excited about, and takes her tomboy look into actual prepubescent territory.
Now Vanessa's, that's a good, but compact but. It's firm and athletic but with enough fat on it to give it a well defined shape and area. There's no question of where her arse ends and her legs begin, even though it isn't anywhere near big enough to be called voluptuous. She's got the absolute best example of an average sized but, and she is rightfully remembered as a legend for it.
We have different definitions here, but at least you're able to DISCUSS! There are so few ass men in the world who has the ability to actually think, analyze and dicuss their favourite topic. I thank you for doing so!
For me, Tracer is category 1. It's a small butt, sure, but I think that is cute in its own way. I for one do not appreciate today's fake, injected silicone butts of celebrities. I think those butts look horrible. Tracer's butt is cute, but the reason I posted her was to compare her ass to Vanessa's.
Vanessa definitely has a firm core, but just as definitely she also has a lot of something else that is not very firm at all. Here's where we differ. For you, hers is average sized. For me, it's big. It's also fat, because it's big. That is not the same as a lardy arse, cellulite and stretch marks. It's just that you can't even see a hint of muscle definition on her ass. It also jiggles quite a bit when she moves around. It bounces around when she runs. When I say she has a fat ass, I mean it literally. It's fat. But I don't mean it as a bad thing. It's a great thing, because it's not TOO fat.
It's just the whole package, really. Because her thighs are pretty slim (although they also jiggle, so they're not firm) and then she has a bubble butt on that. On slim thighs and a wasp waist. That gives it the irresisteble shape. Compare to someone like 2B, who has fat thighs. Her butt doesn't stick out as much as Vanessa's does, and the overall shape of her body is not as good. Also, 2B's butt doesn't jiggle, which instantly puts her behind Vanessa in the rankings.
Ass appreciation is a serious business, it's a science where you have to look at lots of butts to put everything in perspective and understand every inch of the butt. Apart from Vanessa, the best videogame butt I have seen is probably Samus from Zero Mission. You know that shot where her butt looks huge and fat. It's probably the most well drawn 2D butt of all time.
A classic. Zidane practically, with a sense of humor, confirms to the player that her butt is not firm. Otherwise he would have said "Oooh, firm!".