Support NeoGAF

[UberTag]

I can't do episode rankings without a full series re-watch.

1) Sisterhooves Social
2) Everything Else

That's all I've got. But I CAN rank my Top 10 songs.

1) This Day Aria - Britt McKillip
2) Art of the Dress - Kazumi Evans (w/ Shannon Chan-Kent, Ashleigh Ball, Rebecca Shoichet & Andrea Libman)
3) Find a Pet Song - Ashleigh Ball & Andrea Libman
4) Apples to the Core - Ashleigh Ball, Michelle Creber, Peter New, Tabitha St. Germain & Shannon Chan-Kent
5) Winter Wrap Up - Rebecca Shoichet, Ashleigh Ball, Kazumi Evans, Andrea Libman & Shannon Chan-Kent
6) Smile Song - Shannon Chan-Kent (w/ Andrea Libman & Chorus)
7) Becoming Popular - Kazumi Evans (w/ Rebecca Lam)
8) Hearts Strong as Horses - Michelle Creber, Claire Corlett & Madeleine Peters
9) Celestia's Ballad - Nicole Oliver

... and my controversial inclusion... because the song is just too damn catchy...

10) Cafeteria Song - Shannon Chan-Kent, Kazumi Evans, Ashleigh Ball, Andrea Libman & Rebecca Shoichet

 

[PaulloDEC]

... and my controversial inclusion... because the song is just too damn catchy...

10) Cafeteria Song - Shannon Chan-Kent, Kazumi Evans, Ashleigh Ball, Andrea Libman & Rebecca Shoichet

I can't dislike that song, it really is catchy. Will be interesting to see what we get in Rainbow Rocks.

Don't think I've seen this one posted yet:

 

[wildthing2022000]

I can't dislike that song, it really is catchy. Will be interesting to see what we get in Rainbow Rocks.

Don't think I've seen this one posted yet:

Part 2

 

[Tenumi]

Well... Here's my episode list.

1 Hurricane Fluttershy
2 A Canterlot Wedding
3 The Return of Harmony
4 One Bad Apple
5 Sweet and Elite
6 Suited for Success
7 Fall Weather Friends
8 It's About Time
9 Twilight's Kingdom
10 Pinkie Pride
11 Rarity Takes Manehattan
12 May the Best Pet Win!
13 Sisterhooves Social
14 Hearth's Warming Eve
15 Putting Your Hoof Down
16 Testing Testing 1, 2, 3
17 Winter Wrap Up
18 Call of the Cutie
19 MMMystery on the Friendship Express
20 Lesson Zero
21 Sonic Rainboom
22 A Dog and Pony Show
23 Ponyville Confidential
24 The Best Night Ever
25 The Cutie Mark Chronicles
26 A Friend in Deed
27 Wonderbolts Academy
28 Magical Mystery Cure
29 Equestria Girls - Movie
30 The Cutie Pox
31 Daring Don't
32 Castle Mane-ia
33 Princess Twilight Sparkle
34 The Crystal Empire
35 Simple Ways
36 Three's a Crowd
37 Filli Vanilli
38 Look Before You Sleep
39 Trade Ya!
40 Read It and Weep
41 The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000
42 The Show Stoppers
43 Green Isn't Your Color
44 Boast Busters
45 Friendship is Magic
46 Luna Eclipsed
47 Family Appreciation Day
48 Applebuck Season
49 Hearts and Hooves Day
50 Rainbow Falls
51 Power Ponies
52 Magic Duel
53 Stare Master
53 The Last Roundup
55 Party of One
56 Too Many Pinkie Pies
57 Equestria Games
58 Secret of My Excess
59 Maud Pie
60 The Ticket Master
61 It Ain't Easy Being Breezies
62 Swarm of the Century
63 Apple Family Reunion
64 Keep Calm and Flutter On
65 Just For Sidekicks
66 For Whom the Sweetie Belle Toils
67 Twilight Time
68 Flight to the Finish
69 Bats!
70 Games Ponies Play
71 Leap of Faith
72 The Mysterious Mare Do Well
73 Bridle Gossip
74 Pinkie Apple Pie
75 Baby Cakes
76 Sleepless in Ponyville
77 Feeling Pinkie Keen
78 A Bird in the Hoof
79 Dragon Quest
80 Dragonshy
81 Owl's Well That Ends Well
82 Griffon the Brush-Off
83 Inspiration Manifestation
84 Over a Barrel
85 Somepony to Watch Over Me
86 Spike at Your Service

Not too many surprises to me, perhaps to others. I've always tended to have unpopular opinions.

 

[MegamanNG]

Making a list like that would take me days. And I still need to review the final two episodes.

 

[Owlowiscious]

Yay I'm finally on a wall of shameeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee I must keep it up~

 

[Owlowiscious]

.................................... hoot.

 

[McNum]

Aw, I didn't make the wall of shame? I'll have to post harder. Or draw more stuff to post, maybe.

 

[Rhomega Beta]

ahahahahahaha

I immediately thought of T2 when I first saw that.

 

[draetenth]

ahahahahahaha

First thing that came to my mind...

 

[$200]

such 3D

Aw, I didn't make the wall of shame? I'll have to post harder. Or draw more stuff to post, maybe.

Cheerilee should technically be top of the wall. His/her posts are like 10 times longer than the average.

First thing that came to my mind...

Probably did for most people. But I didn't associate the police uniform until I saw this...

 

[UberTag]

Friend over on the Round Stable forums put together an episode ranker. What better way to start a new thread.

http://tinyurl.com/lopyckr
DON'T BE A WUSS AND DO ANY TIES!

Fair enough. Decided I'd tackle this now in advance of any episode marathons over the summer.

THE TOP 10

1 Sisterhooves Social
2 A Canterlot Wedding
3 Hearts and Hooves Day
4 Lesson Zero
5 The Return of Harmony
6 Feeling Pinkie Keen
7 Testing Testing 1, 2, 3
8 A Dog and Pony Show
9 Trade Ya!
10 Suited for Success

GREAT TIER

11 Sonic Rainboom
12 Stare Master
13 Pinkie Pride
14 Magical Mystery Cure
15 Ponyville Confidential
16 Simple Ways
17 Sleepless in Ponyville
18 It's About Time
19 Hurricane Fluttershy
20 Twilight Time
21 Rarity Takes Manehattan
22 Wonderbolts Academy
23 For Whom the Sweetie Belle Toils
24 Maud Pie
25 Pinkie Apple Pie
26 Winter Wrap Up
27 Sweet and Elite
28 Boast Busters

DECENT TIER

29 Read It and Weep
30 The Last Roundup
31 Luna Eclipsed
32 Bridle Gossip
33 Secret of My Excess
34 Dragonshy
35 Magic Duel
36 Castle Mane-ia
37 Flight to the Finish
38 Green Isn't Your Color
39 Filli Vanilli
40 The Cutie Mark Chronicles
41 Friendship is Magic
42 Family Appreciation Day
43 Equestria Girls - Movie
44 MMMystery on the Friendship Express
45 Baby Cakes
46 Too Many Pinkie Pies
47 Somepony to Watch Over Me
48 The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000

MEH TIER

49 Three's a Crowd
50 Look Before You Sleep
51 Leap of Faith
52 The Crystal Empire
53 Putting Your Hoof Down
54 The Best Night Ever
55 May the Best Pet Win!
56 The Cutie Pox
57 Fall Weather Friends
58 A Bird in the Hoof
59 Applebuck Season
60 Call of the Cutie
61 Princess Twilight Sparkle
62 Apple Family Reunion
63 Just For Sidekicks
64 Games Ponies Play
65 Keep Calm and Flutter On
66 One Bad Apple
67 A Friend in Deed
68 Power Ponies
69 Twilight's Kingdom
70 Inspiration Manifestation

THE EPISODES I WOULD RATHER NOT WATCH AGAIN TIER

71 Party of One
72 Rainbow Falls
73 The Show Stoppers
74 Daring Don't
75 Equestria Games
76 Hearth's Warming Eve
77 Over a Barrel
78 The Ticket Master
79 Swarm of the Century
80 Spike at Your Service
81 Dragon Quest
82 The Mysterious Mare Do Well
83 Owl's Well That Ends Well
84 Griffon the Brush-Off
85 It Ain't Easy Being Breezies
86 Bats!

 

[PaulloDEC]

Fair enough. Decided I'd tackle this now in advance of any episode marathons over the summer.

Speaking of, has PonyGAF ever done an organised marathon? A couple of episodes a week wouldn't be too much of a time commitment, and it'd probably take us right up to the start of S5. Could be fun.

 

[Cheerilee]

Cheerilee should technically be top of the wall. His/her posts are like 10 times longer than the average.

Nope, I'm #11.

I can safely say that I'm completely normal. I'm the maximum limit of completely not in the top ten. I'm as normal as normal can be.

Although we lost a few members, so I should probably lean back and allow Jud to become the crazy one.

 

[brian577]

Speaking of, has PonyGAF ever done an organised marathon? A couple of episodes a week wouldn't be too much of a time commitment, and it'd probably take us right up to the start of S5. Could be fun.

Before synctube closed we'd usually watch the newest episode the afternoon after it aired and then rewatch the season over the summer.

 

[Rhomega Beta]

Before synctube closed we'd usually watch the newest episode the afternoon after it aired and then rewatch the season over the summer.

We have a new place to watch. Come to the chat for more details.

 

[$200]

Before synctube closed we'd usually watch the newest episode the afternoon after it aired and then rewatch the season over the summer.

...and we would rate the episode too! Check out all the ratings here. Hopefully we will have season 3 and 4 episodes on that list soon.

 

[LuffyZoro]

 

[DrForester]

Just like poor Chewie...

 

[Slamtastic]

Just like poor Chewie...

Not canon.

 

[Owlowiscious]

THE EPISODES I WOULD RATHER NOT WATCH AGAIN TIER
83 Owl's Well That Ends Well

TvT

 

[PaulloDEC]

So I guess these are a thing:

Also, I can't not post this:

 

[Village]

So I guess these are a thing:

:

I love this kind of thing.

When media inside media become real.

I think the same kinda of thing happened in bakuman or something like that

 

[Amibguous Cad]

We have a new place to watch. Come to the chat for more details.

Yeah, synchtube is back. We should organize a huge damn marathon with all four seasons one of these days

 

[UberTag]

Yeah, synchtube is back. We should organize a huge damn marathon with all four seasons one of these days

Factoring in 22 minutes per episode on top of Equestria Girls, you're looking at a marathon runtime of 34 1/2 hours.
That's doable without sleep but you'd be running on fumes towards the end.

 

[PaulloDEC]

Factoring in 22 minutes per episode on top of Equestria Girls, you're looking at a marathon runtime of 34 1/2 hours.
That's doable without sleep but you'd be running on fumes towards the end.

Wait, are we using the word "marathon" in the strictly literal sense? I love MLP, but 34 straight hours sounds like a living hell.

 

[Amibguous Cad]

Factoring in 22 minutes per episode on top of Equestria Girls, you're looking at a marathon runtime of 34 1/2 hours.
That's doable without sleep but you'd be running on fumes towards the end.

Wait, are we using the word "marathon" in the strictly literal sense? I love MLP, but 34 straight hours sounds like a living hell.

I was intending it literally, but more of an ongoing thing where no one would be expected to watch the whole thing straight in a row. Organizing something where we watch a few episodes every weekend to watch the whole series could be fun, as well.

 

[PaulloDEC]

I was intending it literally, but more of an ongoing thing where no one would be expected to watch the whole thing straight in a row. Organizing something where we watch a few episodes every weekend to watch the whole series could be fun, as well.

I was thinking more like the latter. Maybe assign two episodes a week, get everyone to watch the first by Wednesday and the second by Sunday, and then everyone check in on the forums. Folks in the right timezones could stream together and the rest of us could just catch up in the OT.

Just a thought, anyway.

 

[$200]

I was thinking more like the latter. Maybe assign two episodes a week, get everyone to watch the first by Wednesday and the second by Sunday, and then everyone check in on the forums. Folks in the right timezones could stream together and the rest of us could just catch up in the OT.

Just a thought, anyway.

Two episodes per Saturday was what we did for s1 and s2.

 

[DrForester]

...and we would rate the episode too! Check out all the ratings here. Hopefully we will have season 3 and 4 episodes on that list soon.

Sisterhooves Social's ranking is PonyGAF's greatest shame...

 

[UberTag]

Sisterhooves Social's ranking is PonyGAF's greatest shame...

That needs to be rectified. Although to be fair, we already sort of have given the rankings already provided in this thread.
Would take little time to compile an adjusted rankings list based on everyone's submissions from your Episode Sorter link.

We have 9 lists of ranked episodes and Sisterhooves Social's "average" placing out of 86 episodes across those lists is 13.17.
That would put it ahead of a LOT of episodes and possibly put it into the consensus overall Top 10.

 

[PaulloDEC]

Two episodes per Saturday was what we did for s1 and s2.

Sounds like a good way to go.

 

[$200]

Audio version

 

[Choppasmith]

So I guess these are a thing:



Also, I can't not post this:

Just preordered on Amazon. 70$, but it looks really awesome!
http://www.equestriadaily.com/2014/05/full-daring-do-box-set-revealed.html

 

[LuffyZoro]

The first one is my favorite.

 

[Slamtastic]

 

[Village]

damn.

 

[PaulloDEC]

Ouch. The MLP social media team need to lift their game.

 

[Cheerilee]

Ouch. The MLP social media team need to lift their game.

They did. And it was too high for Spike to reach.

Could've been worse. They could have given the "O" nod to Owlowiscious instead of Discord.

 

[DrForester]

It's full of stars...

 

[BY2K]

I didn't watched Season 3 or 4, but I watched the last two episodes and damn... when did this turn into Dragon Ball?

 

[DrForester]

I didn't watched Season 3 or 4, but I watched the last two episodes and damn... when did this turn into Dragon Ball?

Just in those episodes. The middle 22 episodes were pretty much what the show is about. The Premiere and Finale were the "Oh yeah, Twilight's a Princess now" show.

 

[wookieofdoom]

Was kind of bummed there was no episode to look forward to this weekend.

 

[PaulloDEC]

Canterlot High. Great little tumblr, even if it doesn't abide by the comic canon.

A few samples:

Was kind of bummed there was no episode to look forward to this weekend.

Eeyup. Better get settled in.

 

[$200]

 

[DrForester]

It's road trip time with Applejack and Rarity! When the two friends discover they are headed to the same destination, they naturally decide to ride together. A seemingly easy trip turns disastrous when calamity upon calamity interrupts their journey! Will Applejack and Rarity's friendship... or sanity... survive the trip?

Cook and Price dream team doing a Rarity and AJ comic.

 

[wildthing2022000]

Cook and Price dream team doing a Rarity and AJ comic.

Damn wanted a sequel to The Last Roundup with Pinky & Rarity.

 

[wookieofdoom]

Cook and Price dream team doing a Rarity and AJ comic.

Best ponies get best writer and artist? Day one.

 

[Orcastar]

Cook and Price dream team doing a Rarity and AJ comic.

This should be good. Very good.

 

[DrForester]

Best ponies get best writer and artist? Day one.

Nope, just Rarity and AJ but it will no doubt be great.