-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Classical Music GAF
- Thread starter Kadayi
- Start date
Mitsuda Maniac
Member
Mendelssohn violin concerto is my fav. Soooo good
The Scrivener
Member
Been listening to Beethoven for two weeks now, mainly the early piano sonatas and the early symphonies. Wonderful stuff and I never knew classical music and Beethoven was like, good, you know? Probably because it's nowhere to listen to generally and made out to be boring.
I particularly like the fast stuff, for instance the end of the Piano Sonata 1, 4th Movement.
I've got over the feeling like I'm in a war movie or a psycho and just enjoying the music.
Anyway, reading up a bit on Wikipedia about the sonata, it baffles my mind that one needs to understand the copy-pasted below to get the beauty out of it.
Also, I read online an opera singer saying the beauty in the music lies in comparing the composers against other composers, or their earlier works. But this doesn't make sense: if that was the case then one might as well listen to modern music, like Radiohead, because they changed and improved a lot, and then compare them to Muse or Coldplay. Can't a listener just enjoy the music without understanding the context? Also, despite having some knowledge of music theory and practice, there's no way I could ever listen to Beethoven and "hear" what Wikipedia describes below!
So, I'm just trying to ignore the metacommentary and just listen. Maybe read a book on Beethoven, but that's enough.
Cheers to 3 more months of classical music.
Wikipedia on Piano Sonata 1, 4th Movement:
A transitional passage modulates to the dominant-minor key, where a more lyrical but still agitated theme is presented twice. It is noteworthy that Beethoven chose the dominant-minor key as the secondary key, instead of the more conventional relative major. The exposition closes emphatically on C minor, with iterations of the first subject chordal motif.
The recapitulation reprises the whole exposition nearly identically (apart from very slight changes in dynamics and voicings), but significantly all the material is now re-stated in the tonic key (F minor), as would be expected of any conventional sonata form. The movement ends on a fortissimo eighth-note-triplet descending arpeggio, perhaps to give a symmetrical ending to a sonata that opened with a raising arpeggio.
Edit: I remember an interview with Joe Satriani in front of a bunch of fans, and he says he was miffed that no one spotted on one of his albums that all the songs purposefully started with a raising scale. But he refused to say which album lol. Maybe it's not important to "see" the theory to appreciate the beauty.
I particularly like the fast stuff, for instance the end of the Piano Sonata 1, 4th Movement.
I've got over the feeling like I'm in a war movie or a psycho and just enjoying the music.
Anyway, reading up a bit on Wikipedia about the sonata, it baffles my mind that one needs to understand the copy-pasted below to get the beauty out of it.
Also, I read online an opera singer saying the beauty in the music lies in comparing the composers against other composers, or their earlier works. But this doesn't make sense: if that was the case then one might as well listen to modern music, like Radiohead, because they changed and improved a lot, and then compare them to Muse or Coldplay. Can't a listener just enjoy the music without understanding the context? Also, despite having some knowledge of music theory and practice, there's no way I could ever listen to Beethoven and "hear" what Wikipedia describes below!
So, I'm just trying to ignore the metacommentary and just listen. Maybe read a book on Beethoven, but that's enough.
Cheers to 3 more months of classical music.
Wikipedia on Piano Sonata 1, 4th Movement:
A transitional passage modulates to the dominant-minor key, where a more lyrical but still agitated theme is presented twice. It is noteworthy that Beethoven chose the dominant-minor key as the secondary key, instead of the more conventional relative major. The exposition closes emphatically on C minor, with iterations of the first subject chordal motif.
The recapitulation reprises the whole exposition nearly identically (apart from very slight changes in dynamics and voicings), but significantly all the material is now re-stated in the tonic key (F minor), as would be expected of any conventional sonata form. The movement ends on a fortissimo eighth-note-triplet descending arpeggio, perhaps to give a symmetrical ending to a sonata that opened with a raising arpeggio.
Edit: I remember an interview with Joe Satriani in front of a bunch of fans, and he says he was miffed that no one spotted on one of his albums that all the songs purposefully started with a raising scale. But he refused to say which album lol. Maybe it's not important to "see" the theory to appreciate the beauty.
Last edited:
Makariel
Member
I've spent a lot of time the past week listening to Mendelsohn and Tchaikovsky. I've never listened to the whole of Swan Lake before, what a mistake I've made! If you are in the too large group of music enthusiasts that never listened to Swan Lake, do yourself a favour and track down a recording, it's worth it.
Tesseract
Banned
kiiltz
Member
I enjoy Ludovico. Was wondering if he'd get posted here because some classicalheads don't consider him classical because of how pop and trite he can be.
nikolino840
Member
nikolino840
Member
Aestheticisms
Neo Member
Tritsch-Tratsch Polka
Rachmaninoff's 3rd Piano Concerto
Rachmaninoff's 3rd Piano Concerto
Cosmic Smash
Member
From the Battle Royale soundtrack
Last edited:
The Scrivener
Member
A favourite of mine. Listen from 07:19 especially. Can't seem to go back to regular music since "finding" Beethoven in the summer. His Sonatas are perfect. Tool's Fear Inoculum and GY!BE are all I've had on other than Mr. B.
I wish I'd found this when I was a kid (I'm 39 - better late than never!). So Beautiful and healing.
Last edited:
naturalpuerh
Banned
Most of these are musics from the movies.
Makariel
Member
Most of the music in this thread is much older than movies.
Raistandantulus
Member
Kadayi
Banned
Haunting stuff dude
On a lighter note, heard this today on the way back from work: -
Delicate
Last edited:
Tenaciousmo
Member
Since Debussy's claire de lune has already been posted,
I offer you Camille Saint-Saens's Aquarium. my 2nd favorite classical piece.
I offer you Camille Saint-Saens's Aquarium. my 2nd favorite classical piece.
naturalpuerh
Banned
So how old are you?
Makariel
Member
How is that relevant?
Raistandantulus
Member
Scelsi's work is incredible. He deserves more recognition.
In the spirit of the gales of November
Raistandantulus
Member
To accompany the journey
Raistandantulus
Member
tatas nsfw
I admit that I have a soft spot for Erik Satie's music.
In less than two months, George Gershwin's two-piano sheet music for Rhapsody in Blue and also some of the piano sheet music becomes public domain in the US:
Also in the EU and other Life + 70 countries, every composition by Richard Strauss becomes public domain in 2020.
In less than two months, George Gershwin's two-piano sheet music for Rhapsody in Blue and also some of the piano sheet music becomes public domain in the US:
Also in the EU and other Life + 70 countries, every composition by Richard Strauss becomes public domain in 2020.
Raistandantulus
Member
nikolino840
Member
eot
Banned
Are contemporary works fine?
This is my favourite minimalist piece. There's no youtube version of this recording, so I have to link to spotify. It's a piece that builds very slowly, and doesn't have a lot of melody, so if you check it out then give it a few minutes
Simeon ten Holt: Canto Ostinato - Tomoko Mukaiyama
This is my favourite minimalist piece. There's no youtube version of this recording, so I have to link to spotify. It's a piece that builds very slowly, and doesn't have a lot of melody, so if you check it out then give it a few minutes
Simeon ten Holt: Canto Ostinato - Tomoko Mukaiyama
Raistandantulus
Member
New work always seems early.
Raistandantulus
Member
Danny Dudekisser
I paid good money for this Dynex!
Huh. This thread is relevant to my interests. I play piano and - shockingly enough - I'm actually good. My two favorite piano songs have already been posted - Clair de Lune and Liebestraum No 3. I memorized Clair de Lune earlier this year, and after years of practicing it on-and-off, finally got Liebestraum No. 3 memorized in the last month or so. Would recommend.
eot
Banned
Liszt is tough, but you struggle with memorizing songs? I'm not a great musician technically, but memorization isn't something I have such a hard time with.
Danny Dudekisser
I paid good money for this Dynex!
Yeah, definitely find memorization to be pretty difficult... which is a little weird, because my memory is crazy good for other stuff. The interesting part, at least to me, is that I find the difficult parts of songs waaaay easier to memorize. Like, for the longest time, I had the middle section of Clair de Lune down perfectly, but had no idea how to even start on the first two pages, despite that they're comparatively a cinch.
DelireMan7
Member
Contemporary choir music
eot
Banned
Maybe for the difficult parts you have to go more on feeling? Like, if you're playing fast you can't think about every note, it has to kind of play itself
