-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Abandoned Forspoken SteelBooks Found at Dump
- Thread starter Lunatic_Gamer
- Start date
- News Cringe
Doom85
Member
Like, guys, you do realize you cannot always objectively determine a game‘s popularity and sales by what everyone says on Gaf, right? Pokémon sales would be in the toilet if that were the case, and yet the series continues to sell by the bucketload.
I’m not saying the game didn’t probably underperform, but this steelbooks found in the trash shit? Like, steelbooks rarely contain the game itself, they’re usually an extra bonus while the disc is in the standard case. And, you know, it’s RATHER CONVENIENT how the video doesn’t have him opening the steelbook to show if there’s a disc in there or not.
Like, wake me up when some hard data sales are shown, not some 15 second video with barely any context. And I’ll be glad to admit if the game underperformed (doesn’t mean I didn’t have a good time with it, and fuck any shitlord who has a problem with that) when that comes out, but here’s the thing: let’s not sit here and pretend that hypothetically if sales were revealed to be surprisingly high, that a good deal of people (not necessarily you) here would commence all the mental gymnastics to come up with excuses or bullshit to twist the narrative away from the hard facts.
ReBurn
Member
I can totally see empty steelbooks being tossed a month out. They have no value. The people who wanted the game at release have it. With the reviews it received physical sales will have cooled by now with people waiting for a price cut or a used copy. Retailers aren't inclined to just give stuff away, so instead of doing a "free, take as many as you want" they'll toss the steelbooks because they are worthless and are taking up space.
When Cyberpunk shit the bed on console and Best Buy was selling their overstock copies for $10 (why didn't they just send them back to the publisher If that's a thing they can do?) they tossed in 4 empty steelbooks with the two copies I bought.
Retailers these days do not wait until stock gets old and dusty to send it back or dispose of it. If it's taking up space it's costing them money.
Chukhopops
Member
There’s no mental gymnastics, SE themselves said sales were « lackluster ». But I don’t care about how it sold - I’m saying there was no hype for it and it has nothing to do with console wars, exclusivity, GP or anything else.Like, guys, you do realize you cannot always objectively determine a game‘s popularity and sales by what everyone says on Gaf, right? Pokémon sales would be in the toilet if that were the case, and yet the series continues to sell by the bucketload.
I’m not saying the game didn’t probably underperform, but this steelbooks found in the trash shit? Like, steelbooks rarely contain the game itself, they’re usually an extra bonus while the disc is in the standard case. And, you know, it’s RATHER CONVENIENT how the video doesn’t have him opening the steelbook to show if there’s a disc in there or not.
Like, wake me up when some hard data sales are shown, not some 15 second video with barely any context. And I’ll be glad to admit if the game underperformed (doesn’t mean I didn’t have a good time with it, and fuck any shitlord who has a problem with that) when that comes out, but here’s the thing: let’s not sit here and pretend that hypothetically if sales were revealed to be surprisingly high, that a good deal of people (not necessarily you) here would commence all the mental gymnastics to come up with excuses or bullshit to twist the narrative away from the hard facts.
Look at the demo thread and tell me if you think the demo was well received. Or the thread about the marketing videos published before release. Or the review thread. In fact, the more the game was shown, the more negative the response to it became.
Elder Legend
Yoir Aee Member
This game has to be the worst release of 2023 at this point. Thank god, hopefully this is a wake up call to SE to stop making shit games and using shitty old outdated engines.
systemr123
Member
Twitter user maiacelio shared a video in which a number of Forspoken SteelBooks had been found in the garbage. While it was not disclosed where precisely the items were found, it is still surprising to see such a new game treated this way. Seeing merchandise such as this show up in disposal bins and dumpsters isn't quite new. In similar news, Funko is disposing of $36 million worth of figurines following lackluster sales in 2022. While that product line seems to be dealing with more volume than Forspoken, the fact that this video game has only been out for a couple of months really doesn't seem like a good sign.
While avid collectors place a lot of value on PlayStation 5 SteelBooks, the added cost versus the regular packaging of the game could really affect the decision-making when buying items such as these. Understandably, while most SteelBook editions include other additional freebies or content, most consumers will tend to focus on purchasing games which they hold to a higher regard. In line with Forspoken's mixed reviews and continuous criticisms, it seems the trend for the game is downward. While it wasn't confirmed whether the steel cases had the discs inside, just seeing them thrown out for disposal does put a more negative light on the game.
Abandoned Forspoken SteelBooks Found at Dump
More bad news comes to Luminous Productions' Forspoken as several abandoned SteelBooks were recently found discarded in the trash.gamerant.com
Never go full retard, uh woke I mean. No surprises here. Doesn’t look like they really did it though and that this is someone who “put the evidence here themselves”. Game is bad but it’s no ET.
Doom85
Member
You’re not getting what I’m saying at all. Everything I said about steelbooks you didn’t touch upon. Also, a hypothetical situation doesn’t care what reality is. So again, the actual sales being listed (technically not, just that they were lackluster, but anyone who knows game companies knows that can mean anywhere from a few hundred thousand to a few million and still be “lackluster”) do not affect my hypothetical situation and theory about what would follow it.
Essentially, I said, “what would people be doing if hypothetically aliens arrived on Earth yesterday?” and you responded with, “aliens didn’t arrive yesterday.” You hopefully understand why I would be looking at you like this now:
Chukhopops
Member
Honestly, if I learned the game actually sold well, it wouldn’t change my opinion of it at all, which is based on playing the demo. There are lots of games which sell really well and I fundamentally dislike.You’re not getting what I’m saying at all. Everything I said about steelbooks you didn’t touch upon. Also, a hypothetical situation doesn’t care what reality is. So again, the actual sales being listed (technically not, just that they were lackluster, but anyone who knows game companies knows that can mean anywhere from a few hundred thousand to a few million and still be “lackluster”) do not affect my hypothetical situation and theory about what would follow it.
Essentially, I said, “what would people be doing if hypothetically aliens arrived on Earth yesterday?” and you responded with, “aliens didn’t arrive yesterday.” You hopefully understand why I would be looking at you like this now:
It wouldn’t even disappoint me based on what kind of games are popular those days.
Doom85
Member
Right, I said it may not apply to you, just a few other people here seem really intent on proving the game was a failure. Mind you, this is even worse on gamefaqs, three people in particular cannot seem to resist going after anyone who says anything even mildly positive about the game.
I mean, Atomic Heart is probably not for me, but I’m not looking into sales of it all. If people like it, more power to them. If it did well, cool, hope you all get a sequel you enjoy.
Hell, if Forspoken sales are already stated to be lackluster, why did this steelbook video even need to be made? This is like a voting campaign being decided, and then the winner, “okay, I know we already won, but let’s do a recount, maybe we won ever more!” Like, guys, you got the election, you can chill now.
RoboFu
One of the green rats
Yeah, no one would like it then..
StueyDuck
Member
Amazon isn't your everyday game retailer.
Do you have any actual proof that all retailers dump their merch within a month of release?
Knocking down the price or just giving it away makes sense and definitely happens. Buy this and stand a chance to win that. Buy this and get that for free
But retailers aren't just throwing away games or stock that doesnt sell within a month. That is some serious reaching.
You only toss stock if the cost benefit makes sense to do so. And that's it...
The only scenario where this is happening is if steelbooks > number of disc's given... that's the only time where financially it would make sense to bin it.
And if that is the case, that is 100% on the retailer or a clinical error on order. Nothing to do with the game or its quality or how it is selling.. again we are barely a month after release. Games sell for years, especially these days where a patch can dramatically change the game and spike sales
Last edited:
rofif
Member
Returning it to where they found the dialog.
but ff XV only came in steelbook
my forspoken came with normal case and empty steelbook, so you are right here.
but ff XV only came in steelbook
daffyduck
Member
I'm just spitballin here, but, throwing out some trash?
Tams
Member
Like, guys, you do realize you cannot always objectively determine a game‘s popularity and sales by what everyone says on Gaf, right? Pokémon sales would be in the toilet if that were the case, and yet the series continues to sell by the bucketload.
I’m not saying the game didn’t probably underperform, but this steelbooks found in the trash shit? Like, steelbooks rarely contain the game itself, they’re usually an extra bonus while the disc is in the standard case. And, you know, it’s RATHER CONVENIENT how the video doesn’t have him opening the steelbook to show if there’s a disc in there or not.
Like, wake me up when some hard data sales are shown, not some 15 second video with barely any context. And I’ll be glad to admit if the game underperformed (doesn’t mean I didn’t have a good time with it, and fuck any shitlord who has a problem with that) when that comes out, but here’s the thing: let’s not sit here and pretend that hypothetically if sales were revealed to be surprisingly high, that a good deal of people (not necessarily you) here would commence all the mental gymnastics to come up with excuses or bullshit to twist the narrative away from the hard facts.
'GAF' has been wrong about popularity a lot. See, as you mentioned, Pokémon. And the Switch OT is a hilarious read.
But Forspoken hasn't done very well. It dropped down the charts pretty hard, in places the graphics are a major disappointment, the developer got absorbed into Square (which doesn't tend to happen if they do well), and it was mocked online (outside of GAF too) a lot, both pre and post release. I just think not many people were wanting this game.
And the dialogue is unbearably terrible.
Last edited:
ShadyAcshuns
Member
Appears to be a stunt for attention. I'd believe it if the game was dirt cheap already, but it's not. So I'm calling bullshit.
FalsettoVibe
Member
There's a complete obsession about this game failing.
cireza
Member
Oh so it is okay to waste resources by throwing away a bunch of brand new stuff because nobody wants it.
ChorizoPicozo
Member
yep
Werewolf Jones
Member
Steelbooks rightfully where they belong.
ChorizoPicozo
Member
oh and the opposite was true until reality obliterated all those people.
mrmustard
Member
What would you do with it? Storage is money. I've seen my local store trying to sell 20 or so steelbooks (don't remember the game) for 10 Cents and nobody wanted them.
Heimdall_Xtreme
Jim Ryan Fanclub's #1 Member
I did want to buy it, but I'll wait until it's at 20 dollars or less.
Jimmyisback
Member
Hahaha. This is so funny to me.
FalsettoVibe
Member
Not trying to be a jerk but this is a perfect example of people on a certain team who find pleasure in this game failing.
Last edited:
BlitzerRadic
Member
Why would retailers need to dispose shit when there are ebay powersellers willing to pay them money to take product off their hands? (I know someone who does this)
Jimmyisback
Member
Forspoken one if the worst releases I've ever seen. You can't really see that because you are so bias. What's really sad is sony paying millions for two year exclusivity.
Not trying to be a jerk but this is a perfect example of people on a certain team who find pleasure in this game failing.
Eddie-Griffin
Cancer the womens baby so we can pregnant the panda, we are looking for igloos tonight Are you sexy?
If there were more reports showing this maybe, but just one guy you can find that for many games. Maybe they could even do it themselves who knows.
I mean Square already said it underperformed so not sure what more salt is going to do.
I mean Square already said it underperformed so not sure what more salt is going to do.
Jimmyisback
Member
Haha. More excuses for this terrible game. Just stop.
Thebonehead
Member
Played the demo maybe like me.....
FalsettoVibe
Member
Embarrassing. I'm not making excuses.......anyway, thanks for your valuable contribution to my ignore list.
I agree with you Eddie. What is this bizarro universe? lol
Last edited:
Esppiral
Member
Where did I said that?
Ohh the internet that marvelous place ....
mortal
Member
What's your point? That you want to keep dunking on it just because? Most people just move on to the next, better game in their library after voicing their criticisms.
The vast majority of games on the market are considered mediocre. It's not like this is even considered the worst game that ever was.
Last edited:
Sleepwalker
Member
With that out of the way, theyre empty of course, no retailer is gonna throw away a game, hell, best buy has been trying to sell their leftover Deus Ex manking divided stock for years at this point at like $5 CAD a piece and havent given up yet.
Thebonehead
Member
It is multi-platform, unless you don't count PC as a platform
FalsettoVibe
Member
You're right. My bad. Should have said console exclusive.
Last edited:
diffusionx
Member
Stores dump stock all the time, it is why dumpster diving became a thing.
Now did it happen in this case, if the steelbooks are empty then yea they're not going to waste time and money sending it somewhere to be processed, it'll go into the trash. i doubt they'll do it with a new game, especially when i go to the target clearance rack and it has like 8000 copies of Race with Ryan sitting there for years.
I've worked in retail for a couple years. A lot of people managing digital entertainment have absolutely no clue how much they're supposed to buy-in. And in some cases it's literally cheaper to 'write-off' a certain product than giving it shelf space. Some retailers/publishers are also not allowed to sell games under a certain treshold either because it will inadvertedly be bad PR for the game and/or studio.
I remember one of the managers being stuck with like 500~ physical Forza copies for 3+ years because he didn't know about the arrival of Game Pass and eventually they had to be written off/sent back for termination as well.
That doesn't explain how such a recent game ended up in a bin though. That technically wouldn't be legal over here. Maybe different restrictions in a different country or maybe just a smaller and independent game store.
Last edited:
cireza
Member
The issue is not selling them. Maybe they should have not existed to begin with ?
Aenima
Member
Guy that uploaded the video is a massive xbox warrior, he says in the video the game floped so hard Gamestop sent it to trash. Its bullshit. If anything, those are just empty steelbook cases that the store got in excess and since there are only 5 cases in the trash they rather get rid of them than sent them back.
Ugh, that's gross. I fucking hate these console warriors man.
Ash Sparrow
Member
Thebonehead
Member
FFS. Too many threads on here based off these low rent moronsJust took a look at the profile of the guy that posted the video...
People just use them in threads to stir up controversy
I've been subjected to tools like this gimp above / colt / xvault gaming .
Why do people follow these tools?
kiphalfton
Member
Not saying it isn't stupid, but GameStop (and I'm sure other stores as well) do this all the time.
Aenima
Member
Maybe in Narnia you find 1 month old games in the stores trashcans
Last edited:
ChuckeRearmed
Member
Exactly. When the game was announced we had "PS5 exclusive!", "AAA Square Enix exclusive!" and even when launched close to Hi-Fi Rush "top steam charts", "70$ quality". People were trying to elevate the game simply because it was PS5 exclusive and Square Enix game. That's all to it.
Now suddenly "the hate to the game came from Xbox folks", "because not on Game Pass". Hilarious.
From a foregone conclusion that it would be a banger, it became forsaken after a demo and trailers and it will become forgotten soon.
Last edited:
Aenima
Member
Game always looked mediocre, and always had memes because of the cringe and excessive dialog, but Xbox warriors has been doubling down on Forspoken becase Forspoken sold more than Hi-Fi Rush in January in the US or something like that. Its a console warring thing. If the game was multiplatform from day 1 it would be just an average game and ppl had moved on already.
Last edited:
ShadyAcshuns
Member
A large percentage of gaming forum posters want something to fail. This game is not special in that regard.
Not trying to be a jerk but this is a perfect example of people on a certain team who find pleasure in this game failing.
Umbasaborne
Member
What the fuck is wrong with these people? They have to have an actual mental illness to build up their identities around a game console right? Like people like this dude dont actually act this way offline do they? Does this guy masturbate to npd numbers or something?Just took a look at the profile of the guy that posted the video...
Last edited: