What's wrong with illumination?
Their only passable films they’ve done are Despicable Me 1 and 2 and Sing 1. Beyond that, all they’ve done are terrible Dr. Seuss adaptations (meanwhile Netflix managed to make an entire cartoon series based on Green Eggs and Ham not only somehow work but actually be incredible), Despicable Me 3 where the villain was fun but the rest was garbage, Minions 1 where the only good element was the robber family who are in it for only two minutes, Secret Life of Pets 1 had a few good elements but was mostly a ripoff of Toy Story 1, Secret Life of Pets 2 was just three random stories that didn’t tie into each other (really obvious they had a show planned but it fell through and they just stuffed episode plots into a “film”) and the Minions 2 trailer where 80% of it is random screaming and yelling was the most obnoxious thing I witnessed last year. Oh, and Sing 2’s trailers spoiled the ENTIRE climax, like showed a whole scene of the triumphant moment, so they have shit marketing too.
They‘re easily the most creatively bankrupt animation studio of the past 15 years.
I’m hoping for Mario they had people from Nintendo overseeing the script writing to make sure it wasn’t another shitshow. Same thing happened with The Peanuts Movie, Charles Schultz’ grandkids had the power to pull the plug if the film felt like it was going to be disrespectful to the series so the folks at Blue Sky knew they couldn’t fuck it up.